Woodward police chief worries juvenile sex abuse case won't go to trial
Court documents show a 16-year-old made an âarrangement to engage in a sex actâ with a 13-year-old and to occur âas a surprise to the victimâ by a 15-year-old.
Court documents show a 16-year-old made an âarrangement to engage in a sex actâ with a 13-year-old and to occur âas a surprise to the victimâ by a 15-year-old.
Court documents show a 16-year-old made an âarrangement to engage in a sex actâ with a 13-year-old and to occur âas a surprise to the victimâ by a 15-year-old.
A central Iowa police chief says he is concerned about what could come of a teenager involved in a sex abuse case if it doesnât go to trial. The teen is named as the defendant in court documents. Woodward Police Chief Jim Graham says he anticipates the Boone County Attorney dropping the charges.
âIt is eating me alive,â Graham said.
Graham says he wants the Boone County attorney to continue pursuing charges in the case.
According to court documents, the allegations involve a 13-year-old victim and two offenders: a 15-year-old and a 16-year-old.
Graham says the case stems from Woodward Academyâs problematic sexualized behavior treatment program back in November.
âThey do the best they can with the staff they have,â Graham said. âYou just canât watch every person every second of the day.â
Court documents show that back in November, the 16-year-old made an âarrangement to engage in a sex actâ with a 13-year-old. The documents also show the 16-year-old arranged for a sex act to occur âas a surprise to the victimâ by a 15-year-old.
âThe 15-year-old followed the 13-year-old into the bathroom where they engaged in a sex act,â Graham said. âThe 15-year-old then left. The 16-year-old went in and engaged the 13-year-old in a sex act.â
Graham said the 13-year-old came forward first. Then came the 15-year-old who Graham says is being charged in juvenile court.
According to Graham, the 16-year-old denied it.
âThe 16-year-old had been shipped back to Texas,â said Graham, who said the teen is from the state.
Grahamâs investigation led to his request for a warrant for the 16-year-oldâs arrest. He says his officers went down to Texas two weeks ago, detained the 16-year-old, and returned to Iowa. The teen is being charged as an adult.
âThe Boone County attorney asked me to forward him the report again. I sent him the exact same report,â Graham said. âHe then told me he wasnât going to prosecute.â
ÌÇĐÄvlog reached out to Boone County Attorney Matthew Speers. He shared the following statement, which also explains why he cannot fully comment:
âThe Woodward Police Department filed a complaint against Mr. Keaton but a Trial Information has not yet been filed, so I am unable to fully comment about the particulars. This case is in District Court rather than juvenile court because the charge is a forcible felony and this juvenile is 16 years old. This is a crime due to the ages of the juveniles and there is no allegation of force used in the sex act.
Before I file the formal charge I must weigh many different factors including insufficiency of admissible evidence to support the charge, undue hardship caused to the accused or victim, and any other mitigating circumstances. Filing a criminal charge can have a profound impact on both the victim and suspect.
I did have correspondence with the Woodward Police Chief in this matter prior to and after he filed the criminal complaint. He elected to file the charge despite our conversations and my concern that it would be difficult for a jury to return a guilty verdict. His standard to charge is one of probable cause and it is a lesser standard than I must apply now.â
âI understand that thereâs â every case has problems, but thereâs no case that is perfect: that thereâs admission, that thereâs DNA evidence, and that itâs on camera,â said Graham. âThereâs definitely problems with the case, but itâs not that itâs not winnable.â
Graham says he worries about what the future could hold.
âI charged him as an adult. The consequences wouldnât be so light in this if we would follow through with it,â Graham said.
ÌÇĐÄvlog reached out to Shawn Hollenkamp, the executive director of Woodward Academy. He shared the following statement:
âPlease know that at Woodward Academy, we take any and all allegations of misconduct very seriously. The safety, well-being, and dignity of the youth in our care and staff is our highest priority.
When incidents are reported, we follow all applicable local, state, and federal laws, including mandated reporting requirements and cooperation with law enforcement or child welfare agencies as appropriate.
Due to the confidential nature of juvenile records and out of respect for the privacy of all involved, we are unable to comment on specific youth or cases. However, I want to assure you that we are committed to maintaining a safe and secure environment for every individual on our campus.â