vlog

Skip to content
NOWCAST vlog News at 6am Weekday Mornings
Watch on Demand
Advertisement

Should gender identity be taught in elementary school?

A children's book about a transgender girl sparked controversy at a charter school

Should gender identity be taught in elementary school?

A children's book about a transgender girl sparked controversy at a charter school

WEBVTT THE SCHOOL BOARDMEETING IS ENTERING ITS FOURTHHOUR.THE TOPIC IS PITTING PARENTAGAINST PARENT.>>rt THIS SHOULD NOT BE AN ISSUE.NATALI HUNDREDS OF PARENTSPACKED THE SCHOOL BOARD MEETINGFOR A PASSIONATE DEBATE ABOUTGENDER IDENTITY IN THECLASSROOM.>>rt FOR THEM TO SAY THAT THEY CANTEACH MY CHILD ABOUT TRANSGENDERWITHOUT ME EVEN KNOWING ABOUT ITIS WRONG.NATALIE:rt SOME PARENTS PROPOSED ANEW POLICY REQUIRING THE SCHOOLTO LET THEM KNOW ABOUTCONTROVERSIAL TOPICS AND ALLOWTHEIR STUDENTS TO OPT OUT.>>rt THE SCHOOL HAS TO NOTIFY USFOR EVERY LITTLE THING THEYTHINK MIGHT BE CONTROVERSIAL, WEWOULD HAVE A PERMISSION SLIPCOMING HOME EVERY DAY.IT'S A SLIPPERY SLOPE.NATALIE: THIS DEBATE SrtPARKED INJUNE, WHEN A TRANSGENDER CHILDBROUGHT THE BOOK "I AM JAZZ"ABOUT A CHILD IN TRANSITION, TOCLASS AND HAD THE TEACHER READITrt ALOUD TO LET THE OTHERSTUDENTS KNOW WHAT SHE WAS GOINGTHROUGH.SOME PARENTS SAY THEIR KIDS CAMEHOME QUESTIONING THEIR GENDER.>>rt THIS BOOK WAS OUTSIDE THECURRICULUM, AND I SEE IT AS ACONTROVERSIAL SUBJECT TO DISCUSSWITH KINDERGARTENERS. NATALIE: ANKUR DHAWAN'S DAUGHTERWAS IN THAT CLASS.>>rt THIS CHILD NEEDS US TO COMETOGETHER AS A COMMUNITY ANDRESPECT THEIR DIGNITY AND THEIRCHARACTER AND THEIR INTRINSICWORTH.NATALIE: CALIFORNIA LAW ALLOWSPARENTS TO OPT OUT OF SEXEDUCATION, BUT GENDER IDENTITYDOESN'T FALL UNDER THATrtCATEGORY.>> IT'S LIKE RACE OR RELIGION ORETHNICITY.IT'S A PROTECTED CLASS BUT IT'SNOT SEX ED.SO PARENTS ACTUALLY DON'T HAVETHE OPPORTUNITrtY TO OPT OUT ANDIT WOULD BE ILLEGAL FOR THESCHOOL TO MAKE IT POSSIBLE TOOPT OUT.>> IT DOES NOT PROHIBIT ANSCHOOL DISTRICT FROM PROVIDINGrtAN OPT-OUT PROVISION FOR SCHOOLDISTRICTS, SO FOR THEM TO SAYTHAT IS JUST DISINGENUOUS.NATALIE: THE SCHOOL BOARD DIDCONSIDER GIVING PARENTS NOTICEABOUT TOPICS SO THEY CAN TALK TOrtTHEIR KIDS FIRST.>> THE SCHOOL IS GOING TOENDEAVOR TO DO THAT, AND IF THEYCAN'T GET TO IT AHEAD OF IT,THEY WILL TRY TO INFORM THE
Advertisement
Should gender identity be taught in elementary school?

A children's book about a transgender girl sparked controversy at a charter school

A California school board voted late Monday night in favor of a literary policy that allows controversial books like "I Am Jazz," which tells the story of a transgender girl, to be read in class and won't allow parents the option of opting their children out of that lesson.However, the school will "endeavor" to notify parents about such controversial topics.Hundreds of parents packed the charter school board meeting for the Rocklin Academy Family of Schools Monday for a passionate debate about gender identity and its place in the classroom.Some parents proposed a new policy requiring the charter school to let them know if controversial topics, like gender identity, would be discussed in class and allow their students to opt out."For them to say that they can teach my child about transgender without me even knowing about it is wrong," said parent Chelsea McQuistan, who has two children who attend Rocklin Academy Gateway and a third who is about to enter kindergarten."Gender and sexuality are not the same thing, and I think we end up in a place where parents can opt out of anything they find offensive, which is subjective," said Jen Hansen, another parent in the charter school. The debate was sparked in June when a Rocklin Academy Gateway transgender student brought the book "I Am Jazz," to her kindergarten class. She then asked the teacher to read the book, which is about a transgender girl's transition, to the class so other students knew what she was going through. Some parents said their children came home questioning their gender after school."This book was outside the curriculum and I see it as a controversial subject to discuss with a kindergartner," said Wendy Sickler, who is the parent of two kids at Rocklin Academy Gateway. Ankur Dhawan's daughter was in class when the teacher read "I Am Jazz" to students and was taken aback when she told him about it. "I've struggled with the question of parental notification quite a bit. But when I put my need against the child who's going through that transition, I realized it's not the same thing," Dhawan said. "This child needs us to come together as a community and respect their dignity and their character."California law allows parents to opt out of sex education, but gender identity doesn't fall under that category."It's like race or religion or ethnicity. It's a protected class but it's not sex ed so parents actually don't have the opportunity to opt out and it would be illegal for the school to make it possible to opt out," said Elizabeth Ashford, who works for Fiona Hutton and Associates, the public relations firm hired by Rocklin Academy to serve as spokesperson."It does not prohibit an opt-out provision for school districts, so for them to say that is just disingenuous," California Family Council Director Greg Burt said in response to Ashford's statement.The school board heard more than three hours of comment before they voted late Monday to not to change their current literature policy, which allows the inclusion of transgender characters, and "endeavor" to notify parents about controversial topics. "The school is going to endeavor to do that," Ashford said. "If they can't get to it ahead of it, they will try to inform the parents after the fact." The board also struck down a proposal to allow parents to opt out of gender identity topics in class. Rocklin Academy said 14 families have chosen to disenroll from their charter schools as a result of this issue, and they expect more families to withdraw in the wake of the board meeting.

A California school board voted late Monday night in favor of a literary policy that allows controversial books like "I Am Jazz," which tells the story of a transgender girl, to be read in class and won't allow parents the option of opting their children out of that lesson.

However, the school will "endeavor" to notify parents about such controversial topics.

Advertisement

Related Content

Hundreds of parents packed the charter school board meeting for the Rocklin Academy Family of Schools Monday for a passionate debate about gender identity and its place in the classroom.

Some parents proposed a new policy requiring the charter school to let them know if controversial topics, like gender identity, would be discussed in class and allow their students to opt out.

"For them to say that they can teach my child about transgender without me even knowing about it is wrong," said parent Chelsea McQuistan, who has two children who attend Rocklin Academy Gateway and a third who is about to enter kindergarten.

"Gender and sexuality are not the same thing, and I think we end up in a place where parents can opt out of anything they find offensive, which is subjective," said Jen Hansen, another parent in the charter school.

The debate was sparked in June when a Rocklin Academy Gateway transgender student brought the book "I Am Jazz," to her kindergarten class. She then asked the teacher to read the book, which is about a transgender girl's transition, to the class so other students knew what she was going through.

Some parents said their children came home questioning their gender after school.

"This book was outside the curriculum and I see it as a controversial subject to discuss with a kindergartner," said Wendy Sickler, who is the parent of two kids at Rocklin Academy Gateway.

Ankur Dhawan's daughter was in class when the teacher read "I Am Jazz" to students and was taken aback when she told him about it.

"I've struggled with the question of parental notification quite a bit. But when I put my need against the child who's going through that transition, I realized it's not the same thing," Dhawan said. "This child needs us to come together as a community and respect their dignity and their character."

California law allows parents to opt out of sex education, but gender identity doesn't fall under that category.

"It's like race or religion or ethnicity. It's a protected class but it's not sex ed so parents actually don't have the opportunity to opt out and it would be illegal for the school to make it possible to opt out," said Elizabeth Ashford, who works for Fiona Hutton and Associates, the public relations firm hired by Rocklin Academy to serve as spokesperson.

"It does not prohibit an opt-out provision for school districts, so for them to say that is just disingenuous," California Family Council Director Greg Burt said in response to Ashford's statement.

The school board heard more than three hours of comment before they voted late Monday to not to change their current literature policy, which allows the inclusion of transgender characters, and "endeavor" to notify parents about controversial topics.

"The school is going to endeavor to do that," Ashford said. "If they can't get to it ahead of it, they will try to inform the parents after the fact."

The board also struck down a proposal to allow parents to opt out of gender identity topics in class.

Rocklin Academy said 14 families have chosen to disenroll from their charter schools as a result of this issue, and they expect more families to withdraw in the wake of the board meeting.