Alec Baldwin pleads not guilty to involuntary manslaughter charge in fatal film-set shooting
Updated: 6:42 PM CST Jan 31, 2024
WITH A SINGLE GUNSHOT, THE FOCUS TURNS TO NEW MEXICO. BUT BONANZA CREEK LAND PEOPLE ACCIDENTALLY SHOT ON A MOVIE SET BY A PROP GUN. QUESTIONS EMERGING ABOUT SAFETY. TO SEE A LIVE BULLET IN PLAY. AND FOR ANYBODY WORKING IN THIS BUSINESS THATâS SO FAR OUT OF THE REALM OF WORTHLESS, POSSIBLE EVEN. WHO IS RESPONSE? REBEL. DAVID HULSE. ALEC BALDWIN, HANNAH GUTIERREZ-REED. AND WILL ANYONE BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE? THEREâS A LOT THAT CAN HAPPEN BETWEEN NOW AND A TRIAL. GOOD EVENING. IâM DOUG FERNANDEZ AND IâM SHELLY RIBANDO. THANK YOU FOR JOINING US FOR THIS TARGET 7 INVESTIGATIVE SPECIAL RESTED THE SANTA FE COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY IS CHARGING THREE PEOPLE IN CONNECTION WITH THE OCTOBER 2021 SHOOTING DEATH OF CINEMATOGRAPHER HALYNA HUTCHINS. THE FBI SAYS ACTOR ALEC BALDWIN PULLED THE TRIGGER. HE AND SET ARMORER HANNAH GUTIERREZ-REED HAVE BEEN CHARGED WITH INVOLUNTARY MANSLAUGHTER AND IF CONVICTED, THEY COULD SERVE AS MUCH AS SIX AND A HALF YEARS IN PRISON. ASSISTANT DIRECTOR DAVID HALL, WHO ALSO HANDLED THE GUN THAT DAY, REACHED A PLEA DEAL AND WILL DO SIX MONTHS PROBATION FOR A PETTY MISDEMEANOR. SINCE DAY ONE, TARGET 7 IS CLOSELY FOLLOW THE INVESTIGATION. OUR TEAM COMBED THROUGH HUNDREDS OF PAGES OF DOCUMENTS, ANALYZE LAPEL VIDEO AND INTERVIEWED EXPERTS. WHAT THEY FOUND DIGGING INTO THAT DAY IN OCTOBER COULD AFFECT WHETHER ANYONE IS HELD ACCOUNTABLE. SOME OF WHAT YOUâLL SEE TONIGHT HAS NEVER BEEN AIRED. HERE IS TARGET 7 JOHN MARTINELLI, OCTOBER 21ST, 2021. IT WAS A NICE FALL DAY IN SANTA FE COUNTY, 60 DEGREES AND CLEAR SKIES AS CREWS WERE ARRIVING TO BONANZA CREEK RANCH. THEY LOOK LIKE THE OLD WESTERN TOWNS BACK IN THE 1800S. AND THIS IS WHAT THIS IS, IS A PIONEER TOWN, 1800S BEFORE HER DEATH. IMOGENE HUGHES OWNED THE RANCH. THIS REALLY IS WHERE THE FILMING STARTED. BIG TIME WESTERNS WERE MADE AT BONANZA CREEK, YOUNG GUNS, SILVERADO AND LONESOME DOVE. THE MOVIE RUST, STARRING ALEC BALDWIN, WAS GOING TO JOIN THAT LIST. EVERYBODY LIKES THIS TOWN. THE FILM IS SET IN 1880S KANSAS. ITâS ABOUT A 13 YEAR OLD BOY WHO GOES ON THE RUN WITH HIS GRANDFATHER, A MAN SENTENCED TO HANG FOR ACCIDENTALLY KILLING A LOCAL RANCHER. IT WAS THE 16TH DAY OF FILMING HERE AT BONANZA CREEK RANCH, BUT SOMETHING WAS WRONG. SEVERAL CREW MEMBERS DIDNâT SHOW UP BECAUSE THEY FELT THE SET WASNâT SAFE. THE GUN SAFETY, A LACK OF REHEARSALS, A LACK OF, YOU KNOW, PREPARING THE CREW FOR FOR WHAT WE WERE DOING THAT DAY. OTHERS DISAGREED, BUT WE HAD ALREADY DONE QUITE A BIT OF WORK AND I NEVER FELT UNSAFE. LITERALLY, WE HAD ALREADY SHOT AND KILLED FIVE, SIX, EIGHT GUYS. I DONâT REMEMBER. NOT LITERALLY, OF COURSE, BUT WITH A SINGLE SHOT. ALL OF THAT CHANGED AND SOMEONE DID ACTUALLY DIE. THE SANTA FE 32, THE STATE OF EMERGENCY. IT WAS SHORTLY BEFORE 2 P.M. THIS CALL CAME IN THE 911 AT BONANZA CREEK GRANT. PEOPLE ACCIDENTALLY SHOT ON A MOVIE SET BY A PROP GUN. WE NEED HELP IMMEDIATELY, ANSWERED CRAIG GRANT. COME ON. SHERIFFâS DEPUTIES, PARAMEDICS AND FIREFIGHTERS RUSHING TO THE SCENE. YOU GOT YOUR PICTURE? YEAH. IâM TRYING TO GET IT OUT. THEY GET THERE TO FIND OUT. ACTOR ALEC BALDWIN WAS HOLDING THIS GUN. THAT FIRE AT A BULLET HITTING CINEMATOGRAPHER HELENA HUTCHINS AND DIRECTOR JOEL SOUZA. THE SCENE WAS CHAOTIC. PARAMEDICS TRYING TO HELP THE INJURED. SHE CAME IN HERE AND WENT ACROSS HER CHEST AND CAME BACK. AND WHEN POLICE TRYING TO FIGURE OUT WHAT HAPPENED. ALEC BALDWIN, CONTRACTOR, WAS THE ONE TO PULL THE TRIGGER. YOU WONâT HAVE ANY. YOU JUST HAVE TO SIT TIGHT. CREW MEMBERS PANICKING. SHE LOOKED SO SCARED. JUST RELAX. THE FOCUS. OKAY. INVESTIGATORS TRYING TO GET TO THE TRUTH. SO NOW LET ME ASK YOU, DID YOU SEE THE ROUNDS THAT WERE IN THE GUN? NO. HUTCHINS WOUNDS SO SEVERE. CREWS HAD TO LIFEFLIGHT HER TO ALBUQUERQUE AS SHE FOUGHT FOR HER LIFE. THEN REALITY SINKS IN. AND YOU HAVE SOME VERY UNFORTUNATE -- IS TO TELL YOU WHAT SHE DIDNâT GET. YEAH. THIS IS HALYNA HUTCHINS. SHE WAS BORN IN UKRAINE AND CAME TO THE UNITED STATES TO PURSUE A CAREER IN FILM. SHE WAS THE MOTHER OF A NINE YEAR OLD BOY, A WIFE, AND AN UP AND COMING CINEMATOGRAPHER WITH A LOT OF RESPECT. HER DEATH HERE AT BONANZA CREEK RANCH, THAT DAY SPIRALED INTO A 15 MONTH LONG INVESTIGATION. OUR TARGET 7 TEAM STAYED ON TOP OF IT, TOOK THAT LONG FOR THE SANTA FE COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY MARY CORMACK, ALWAYS TO DECIDE WHO SHOULD BE CHARGED. WE DETERMINED THAT THERE WERE THREE PEOPLE THAT WERE THE MOST CULPABLE, AND THOSE ARE THE THREE THAT EITHER TOUCHED THE GUN THAT DAY OR HAD HE HAD A DUTY TO HAVE TOUCHED OR CHECKED THE GUN THAT DAY. THE D.A. SAYS THESE THREE PEOPLE ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR ACTOR ALEC BALDWIN. ONE OF THE PRODUCERS OF THE MOVIE, WHO ALSO HAD THE LEAD ROLE. POLICE SAY HE FIRED THE GUN. I WAS RECENTLY THE GUN. THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR, DAVID HALLâS NINE YEAR. THEREâS ONE THERE AND THEREâS ONE THERE. THATâS NONE OF THAT STUFF. COURT DOCUMENTS SAY HE HANDED THE GUN TO BALDWIN AND ANNOUNCED IT WAS SAFE. HE IS THE ONE WHO REACHED A PLEA AGREEMENT AND ARMORER HANNAH GUTIERREZ-REED, A 25 YEAR OLD WHO JUST STARTED IN THE FILM BUSINESS. SHE WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE GUNS ON SET AND LOADED THIS COLT 45 BEFORE GIVING IT TO HALL. SO DO I KNOW THIS IS A GUN? THATâS THE GUN. OKAY. WHAT WAS YOUR REACTION WHEN YOU FIRST LEARNED ABOUT WHAT HAPPENED AT BONANZA CREEK RANCH? YOU KNOW, I THINK LIKE EVERYBODY ELSE, YOUâRE STUNNED THAT ON A MOVIE SET THAT THERE ARE LIVE BULLETS BEING USED AND AND HOW CAN THAT HAPPEN? HOW CAN SOMEBODY CINEMA TOGGLE FOR GET SHOT ON A MOVIE SET IN NEW MEXICO? JOHN DAY IS A FORMER PROSECUTOR AND IS KOAT LEGAL EXPERT. HE SAYS THAT WHILE IT MAY SEEM LIKE AN OPEN AND SHUT CASE, NOTHING IS GUARANTEED. ITâS NOT A WHODUNIT. WE KNOW WHO PULLED THE TRIGGER. WE KNOW WHO WAS HOLDING THE GUN. WE KNOW WHO THE PLAYERS WERE. BUT AT THE END OF THE DAY, WEâLL SEE WHAT HAPPENS. DOES SHE GET CONVICTIONS? ARE THERE ACQUITTALS? DAY SAYS ITâS LIKELY THE CASE WILL GO BEFORE A JURY HERE AT THE SANTA FE COUNTY DISTRICT COURTHOUSE. BUT GETTING CONVICTIONS ON BALDWIN AND GUTIERREZ-REED MAY PROVE TO BE DIFFICULT COURT. DURING OUR INVESTIGATION, WE FOUND FLAWS IN HOW WITNESSES WERE SEPARATED. CONTRADICTIONS ON WHETHER THE GUN COULD FIRE ON ITS OWN. AND QUESTIONS ABOUT HOW SAFE THE SET WAS IN THE FIRST PLACE. THAT EVERYONE IS EQUAL UNDER THE LAW. AND IF YOUâRE GOING TO HOLD AN INHERENTLY DANGEROUS WEAPON AND THEN PULL THE TRIGGER WHILE POINTING IT AT SOMEONE, YOUâRE GOING TO BE HELD ACCOUNTABLE FOR THAT. IN THE DAYS AND WEEKS FOLLOWING THAT TRAGIC DAY, SO MUCH MORE WOULD COME TO LIGHT, INCLUDING THE WAY INVESTIGATORS HANDLED EVIDENCE THAT COULD IMPACT THE CASE. AND WAS ALEC BALDWIN GIVEN SPECIAL TREATMENT? AND WHY DID BALDWIN BELIEVE HE WOULDNâT BE CHARGED IF SOMEBODY INTRUDES TO STAY ALIVE? UNTIL THAT SET, THAT PERSON SHOULD BE CHARGED AND THAT INVESTIGATION SHOULD HAVE BEEN DONE. YOU MAY HAVE ALEC BALDWIN TAKE A SEAT BACK ON UNIT OR NO. WE KNOW WHERE HEâS, YOU KNOW. YEAH. YOU KNOW, HINDSIGHT BEING 2020, I CAN SEE THAT THERE WERE, IN FACT, SOME MISTAKES MADE. WERE MISTAKES MADE. WHEN DEPUTIES WERE CALLED TO RESPOND TO THE SHOOTING ON THE SET OF THE MOVIE RUST, THEY FOUND TWO PEOPLE WITH GUNSHOT WOUNDS. THERE WERE NEARLY 200 POSSIBLE WITNESSES, THOUSANDS OF PIECES OF EVIDENCE AND A POSSIBLE CRIME SCENE. THEY WERE RESPONSIBLE FOR. AT THE TIME. THEY HAD NO IDEA IF A CRIME WAS COMMITTED AND IF SOME OF THE PEOPLE THEY WERE TALKING TO COULD END UP BEING CHARGED. EVERYTHING THEY DID WAS RECORDED ON CAMERAS. THEY WERE WEARING. AND IT IS LIKELY TO BE CRITIQUED IF THE CASE GOES TO TRIAL. ONCE AGAIN, HEREâS TARGET 7 JOHN CARDINAL LEE. YOU KNOW, YOU COULD GO TEN. LAW ENFORCEMENT CAREERS EASILY WITHOUT EVER BEING IN A SITUATION WHERE YOUâRE ON THE SCENE AND SOMEBODY IS DECEASED. AND THE WORD PROP GUN IS BEING THROWN AROUND. RETIRED POLICE COMMANDER PAUL ZICK HAS INVESTIGATED DOZENS OF HOMICIDES. HE LOOKED AT HOURS OF ON BODY CAMERA FOOTAGE RELEASED BY THE SANTA FE COUNTY SHERIFFâS OFFICE MONTHS AFTER THE DEATH OF HALYNA HUTCHINS. SO I CAN SEE THAT THE OFFICERS REALLY TRYING TO GET HIS MIND AROUND, YOU KNOW, WHAT DO I HAVE HERE? AT FIRST, TWO DEPUTIES WERE TOLD THEY WERE RESPONDING TO AN ACCIDENTAL SHOOTING THAT INVOLVED THE PROP GUN. AND ONE OF THE THINGS DEPUTIES NEEDED TO DO IMMEDIATELY SEPARATE EVERYONE TRIED TO KEEP HIM AWAY FROM EVERYBODY. OKAY. I HAVENâT TALKED TO ANYBODY. I CAN JUST I CAN SIT WITH THEM IN MY UNIT. THATâS FINE. OKAY. THATâS ALLOWED. TENNENT TELLING A DEPUTY TO KEEP ACTOR ALEC BALDWIN AWAY FROM PEOPLE. YOU GOT TWO SEPARATE PEOPLE AND YOU GOT TO TAKE CONTROL OF THE SCENE. THATâS THE REALITY. BUT THAT DIDNâT HAPPEN RIGHT AWAY. IâM HAPPY TO STAY RIGHT HERE AND DO EVERYTHING. WELL, LISTEN, I JUST WANT YOU TO STAY AWAY FROM EVERYBODY, NOT TO TALK TO NOBODY. SO I WAS RIGHT HERE. WE CAN BE RIGHT HERE AND HAVE EVERYBODY SIT BACK OR WE CAN WAIT THEM BACK FOR PETROLEUM. BUT I PREFER TO NOT PUT YOU THERE. OKAY. THE REAL POWER ON THE SCENE, AS YOU KNOW, IS THIS VERY POPULAR ACTOR. WERE MISTAKES MADE? I WONâT SPEAK TO SPECIFICS, BUT IâLL SAY THIS. THEREâS NO PERFECT RESPONSE AND NO PERFECT CRIME SCENE. SANTA FE COUNTY SHERIFF FIDAN MENDOZA SAID HIS DEPARTMENT COULD HAVE DONE A BETTER JOB WITH THE INVESTIGATION. IF YOU DONâT GO BACK AND LOOK AT AT HOW YOU CAN DO THINGS BETTER THAN THEN, WEâRE NOT DOING THE BEST JOB THAT WE CAN. I WAS WATCHING FOR THE NEXT 26 MINUTES. BALDWIN IS SEEN INTERACTING WITH 11 DIFFERENT PEOPLE UNTIL THE DEPUTY SAYS THIS PARTY, GUYS, IF I CAN HAVE YOU GUYS STOP TALKING ABOUT THE INCIDENT UNTIL EVERYBODYâS BEEN INTERVIEWED SEPARATELY. OKAY. AT ONE POINT, BALDWIN WAS TALKING TO THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR, DAVID HALLâS. REMEMBER HIM? HEâS THE ONE WHO REACHED A PLEA AGREEMENT. HE PLED TO A PETTY MISDEMEANOR AND GOT PROBATION. HE MAKES A GESTURE TO BALDWIN ABOUT HOW AMMUNITION IS CHECK. WHEN YOU HEAR ENOUGH PEOPLE SAY THINGS A DIFFERENT WAY, ITâS VERY EASY FOR YOU TO THEN BEGIN TO HAVE YOUR REALITY BE WHAT OTHERS ARE SAYING. SO BALDWIN SHOULD HAVE BEEN SEPARATED, IDEALLY. IDEALLY, HE SHOULD HAVE BEEN SEPARATED FROM ANYBODY. AND, YOU KNOW, WE WANT THE STATEMENT AND WHAT HEâS RECALLING OF THE INCIDENT TO BE AS AUTHENTIC AND GENUINE AS POSSIBLE. IS THAT A POLICY VIOLATION OR IS IT BAD PRACTICE? YES. AND IT IS SOMETHING THAT WE COULD HAVE THAT THE DEPUTY COULD HAVE DONE BETTER, PROBABLY. IS THAT GOING TO AFFECT THIS CASE AT ALL? I DONâT THINK SO. THIS WAS AN UNINTENTIONAL SHOOTING. IT WAS CRIMINAL, BUT IT WAS STILL UNINTENTIONAL. SO THERE WAS NO REASON FOR PEOPLE TO LIE, TO GET TOGETHER, TO COLLUDE. I DONâT THINK THAT THAT HAPPENED AND I DONâT THINK IT AFFECTS THE INVESTIGATION WHATSOEVER. I THINK THE QUALITY OF THE INVESTIGATION IS GOING TO BE AN ISSUE IN THIS CASE. JASON BOLES REPRESENTS ARMOR HANNAH GUTIERREZ-REED. WE ARE GOING TO BRING UP AS THIS GOES ON WHY THAT IS SIGNIFICANT AND WHY ITâS IMPORTANT AND WHY CERTAIN THINGS MATTER. ITâS POLICE ONE ON ONE. BUT AFTER A CRIME OCCURS, YOU SEPARATE ALL THE POTENTIAL SUSPECTS AND WITNESSES SO THAT THEYâRE NOT ALLOWED TO COMMUNICATE. OUR CLIENT WAS IMMEDIATELY SEPARATED, TAKEN INTO THE BACK OF THE PATROL UNIT, AND SHE WAS TREATED DIFFERENTLY THAN MR. BALDWIN. HOW THE INVESTIGATION WAS HANDLED IS ONE OF MANY ISSUES LIKELY TO COME UP IF THE CASE GOES TO TRIAL. WHAT BALDWIN SAID THAT DAY HAS VARIED AND WHETHER A GUN LIKE THIS CAN FIRE ON ITS OWN HAS BEEN DEBATED. HOURS AFTER THE SHOOTING, HE SAID THIS WHEN QUESTIONED BY INVESTIGATORS. I MEAN, I DONâT WANT TO TELL YOU YOUR JOB. IâM SO SICK ABOUT THIS IS SICKENED BY THIS THAT A BULLET PASSED THROUGH THIS GIRLâS BODY. SHEâS IN CRITICAL CONDITION AT A HOSPITAL RIGHT NOW. AND I FIRED THE GUN. BUT WHEN HE SAT DOWN WITH ABCâS GEORGE STEPHANOPOULOS, HE HAD THIS TO SAY. IT WASNâT IN THE SCRIPT FOR THE TRIGGER TO BE PULLED OR THE TRIGGER WASNâT PULLED. I DIDNâT PULL THE TRIGGER. YOU NEVER WANT TO POINT AT ANYBODY RIGHT? YOU WANT A CLEAR CHECK THE CHAMBERS ON IT. THEREFORE, ITâS EMPTY. ITâS SAFE. WHEN THE SHOOTING OCCURRED, WE WANTED TO KNOW EVERYTHING ABOUT THE F LEE PARTICLE 45, THE GUN USED BY BALDWIN. IT WAS A BIG ADVANCEMENT OVER THE PAST FIREARMS, WHICH ARE PERCUSSION, FIREARMS. ROBERT TIGI SPECIALIZES IN ANTIQUE GUNS. HE WORKS AT RON PETERSONâS GUN SHOP, AND WE PAID HIM A VISIT JUST DAYS AFTER THE SHOOTING. HE SAID ACCIDENTS ARE PASSING, BUT WITH THE GUN BALDWIN HAD IN HIS HAND. THIS IS A SINGLE ACTION AND YOU CAN VERY EASILY ACCIDENTALLY PULL THE HAMMER BACK QUICKLY FROM RIDING THROUGH BRUSH AND IT WOULD IT WOULD END UP IF IT DIDNâT CATCH HALF --, IT WOULD FIRE. BUT THIS REPORT FROM THE FBI SAYS BALDWIN HAD TO HAVE PULLED THE TRIGGER. INVESTIGATORS ALSO COLLECTED VIDEO AND PHOTOS LIKE THIS FROM THE SCENE OF PRIOR REHEARSALS THAT DAY THAT SHOW BALDWINâS FINGER ON THE TRIGGER. AND THATâS WHY THE DISTRICT ATTORNEY IS CHARGING HIM. ALEC BALDWIN HAS SAID HE DID NOT PULL THE TRIGGER. DO WE BELIEVE THAT? NO, THATâS NOT TRUE. THE FBI REPORT SHOWED US THAT THAT GUN WOULD NOT HAVE GONE OFF WITHOUT THE TRIGGER BEING PULLED. SO ALEC BALDWIN DID PULL THE TRIGGER, CORRECT? HE DID. DO WE KNOW HOW A LIVE ROUND GOT INTO THE GUN THAT DAY? WE KNOW HOW IT GOT INTO THE GUN. WE DONâT KNOW HOW IT GOT ONTO THE SET. THE WAY IT GOT INTO THE GUN WAS THAT HANNAH GUTIERREZ-REED LOADED IT INTO THE GUN. SIX LIVE ROUNDS WERE FOUND AT THE RUS MOVIE SET, COUNTING THE ONE THAT WAS FIRED. THERE WAS ALSO ONE FOUND IN THE GUN BELT BALDWIN WAS WEARING AND POLICE TRIED TO FIGURE OUT HOW THEY GOT THERE. THEIR INVESTIGATION LED THEM TO PD Q ARM PROP IN ALBUQUERQUE. THIS IS WHERE SOME OF THE AMMUNITION FOR THE MOVIE WAS PURCHASED. I FOUND A LIVE AROUND IN MY VAN, WHICH WAS WEIRD, AND I WANT TO GIVE IT TO YOU. THAT WAS SETH KENNEY, OWNER OF PD Q ARM AND PROP BEING QUESTIONED BY INVESTIGATORS. AT THE TIME, THEY BELIEVED LIVE AMMUNITION COULD HAVE COME FROM HIS PROP SHOP RIGHT HERE IN ALBUQUERQUE. SHORTLY AFTER THEY SEARCHED THE SHOP HERE AND THEY FOUND LIVE AMMUNITION. DID ANY LIVE ROUNDS FOUND ON THIS SET THAT DAY COME FROM PD Q ARM AND PROP? WE CANNOT SAY THAT THEY DID. DO WE KNOW WHERE THOSE LIVE ROUNDS POTENTIAL IT CAME FROM? WE HAVE THEORIES, BUT WE DO NOT KNOW. EVERYONE ELSE HAS THEIR OWN THEORIES TOO. IN INTERVIEWS WITH THE NATIONAL MEDIA, BALDWIN HAS POINTED FINGERS AT KENNEY. DOES SETH KENNEY PROVIDE HER WITH PROP AMMUNITION WHERE HE CO-MINGLED LIVE ROUNDS WITH BLANK ROUNDS? WHEN QUESTIONED BY POLICE, KENNEY HAS BLAMED GUTIERREZ-REED. IF YOU WANT TO SHOOT LIVE AMMO OUT OF THE GUNS THE TV MOVIE GOT INTO, I SAID, NO WAY. OBVIOUSLY GUTIERREZ-REED ATTORNEY HAS SAID THATâS NOT TRUE. DO YOU STILL BELIEVE THAT SABOTAGE WAS A POSSIBILITY IN THIS CASE? WE DO BELIEVE IT COULD BE A POSSIBILITY. WE BELIEVE SINCE DAY ONE HAS BEEN HOW DID THOSE LIVE ROUNDS GET UNDER SET? EVERYBODY IN AMERICA, IT SEEMS LIKE, IS ASKING THAT QUESTION. THE SHERIFF AND THE D.A. ESSENTIALLY GAVE UP ON INVESTIGATING THAT QUESTION. IS SABOTAGE A POSSIBILITY? NO, IT NEVER WAS. IT WAS SOMETHING THAT WAS FLOATED, I BELIEVE, BY A DEFENSE ATTORNEY. THERE HAS BEEN ABSOLUTELY NO EVIDENCE THAT ANY SABOTAGE OCCURRED. WHATSOEVER. HAVE YOU BEEN ABLE TO DETERMINE WHERE THOSE LIVE ROUNDS MAY HAVE COME FROM? WE HAVE A VERY GOOD IDEA. BOLES CLAIMS THAT INVESTIGATORS DID NOT TRY TO LIFT FINGERPRINTS FROM THE ROUNDS. INVESTIGATORS TOLD TARGET 7 IT WOULD BE HARD TO PULL FINGER PRINTS FROM THE ROUNDS. WILL WE EVER KNOW WHERE THOSE LIVE ROUNDS CAME FROM? I DONâT THINK SO. ALEC BALDWIN SAID HE DIDNâT THINK HEâD BE CHARGED. BUT WHY WAS HE TALKING TO SOMEONE ON THE INSIDE OF THE INVESTIGATION? AND WILL IT HAVE AN EFFECT ON THE CASE? IâVE BEEN TOLD BY PEOPLE WHO ARE IN THE KNOW IN TERMS OF EVEN INSIDE THE STATE, THAT ITâS HIGHLY UNLIKELY. I WOULD BE CHARGED WITH ANYTHING CRIMINALLY. WHY WOULD ALEC BALDWIN BE SO CONFIDENT THAT HE WOULDNâT BE CHARGED IN THIS CASE? IT CERTAINLY DIDNâT COME FROM MY OFFICE BECAUSE WE HAD NO LEAKS. ALEC BALDWIN WAS BASICALLY A DEFENSE ATTORNEY, A NIGHTMARE. ALEC BALDWIN WAS NOT CAMERA SHY WHEN IT CAME TO TELLING HIS STORY ABOUT THE SHOOTING ON THE SET OF THE RUST MOVIE. HE CLAIMED HE DIDNâT PULL THE TRIGGER AND SAID EARLY ON HE WASNâT GOING TO BE CHARGED. BALDWIN CLAIMS SOMEONE IN THE KNOW TOLD HIM HE WAS GOING TO BE OKAY. AND TARGET 7 MAY HAVE DISCOVERED WHO THAT SOMEONE IS. SO WILL THAT HURT THE DAâS CASE? HEREâS JOHN CARD IN L.A. FOLLOWING THE RAW SHOOTING. ALEC BALDWIN HAD A LOT TO SAY ABOUT HOW THE GUN WENT OFF. I NEVER ONCE SAID I NEVER THAT THE GUN WENT OFF IN MY HAND AUTOMATICALLY. I ALWAYS SAID I PULLED THE HAMMER BACK. HOW THIS SHOOTING AFFECTED HIM. AND SHE WAS GREAT AT HER JOB AND SHE DIED AND SHE DIED. AND THATâS THAT HURTS ME EVERY DAY. YOU KNOW, EVERY DAY OF MY LIFE. I THINK ABOUT THAT. ITâS HORRIBLE. AND HOW HE WAS NOT GOING TO BE CHARGED. A PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR, AS YOU PROBABLY KNOW, DID NOT HAVE A DIFFICULT TIME ACCESSING THE STAFF OF THE SHERIFFâS DEPARTMENT. AND THAT PERSON TOLD US, QUOTE UNQUOTE, WEâVE KNOWN IN THE DEPARTMENT SINCE JANUARY THAT ALEC WOULD NOT BE CHARGED WITH A CRIME. TARGET SEVEN HAS LEARNED THAT DURING THE INVESTIGATION, WHEN THIS SHERIFFâS DETECTIVE YOU SEE HERE INTERVIEWING BALDWIN, HAD BEEN COMMUNICATING WITH THE ACTOR. WE OBTAINED COPIES OF THE TEXT MESSAGES BETWEEN THE TWO. HE ASKS HER. IâVE BEEN GETTING SOME CALLS WARNING ME TO GET CRIMINAL COUNSEL. HE SAID, I HAVENâT BEEN CHARGED WITH ANYTHING. DO YOU THINK THEREâS EVEN A POSSIBILITY THAT I WILL BE? I THOUGHT THAT WASNâT PASSIVE BULL. THE DETECTIVE RESPONDS, I HAVE A MEETING WITH THE D.A. TOMORROW AFTERNOON, AND I CAN GIVE YOU A CALL ONCE WE DISCUSS THE TOTALITY OF EVERYTHING I DONâT NECESSARILY SEE ANYTHING PAST A CIVIL LEVEL, BUT IâLL GET A BETTER FEEL TOMORROW. ABOUT TWO WEEKS AFTER THOSE TEXTS, BALDWIN SAYS THIS TO GEORGE. STEPHANIE. IâVE BEEN TOLD BY PEOPLE WHO ARE IN THE KNOW IN TERMS OF EVEN INSIDE THE STATE, THAT ITâS HIGHLY UNLIKELY. I WOULD BE CHARGED WITH ANYTHING CRIMINALLY. THE D.A. THINKS THIS WAS PLANNED BY THE INVESTIGATOR. I BELIEVE THAT SHE WAS USING A TACTIC TO KEEP BALDWIN TALKING WITH HER, TO KEEP HIM FREELY GIVING GIVING HER INFORMATION. AND SO, AGAIN, I HAVE NO CONCERNS WITH HER INVESTIGATION. WELL, IT DEPENDS FROM AN INVESTIGATORY STANDPOINT. ITâS GOING TO DETERMINE WHETHER OR NOT THEY BECOME THE FOCUS OF YOUR INVESTIGATION. REMEMBER. RETIRED POLICE COMMANDER PAUL ZWICK. HE ANALYZED THE TEXT MESSAGES THE INVESTIGATOR SENT. NOW, IF YOUâRE DEALING WITH A WITH A TRUE WITNESS, SOMEBODY WHO YOU HAVE NO INTENTION OF CHARGING, SOMEBODY WHO YOU DONâT BELIEVE THAT THAT HAS ANY CULPABILITY IN THE INVESTIGATION, THATâS FINE. DO YOU THINK THOSE TEXT MESSAGES ARE MAYBE WHY BALDWIN SORT OF ASSUMED THAT HE WOULDNâT BE CHARGED? I CANâT SPECULATE AS TO THAT. ALTMAN SHOULD HAVE KEPT HIS MOUTH SHUT AND WAITED FOR HIS DEFENSE TEAM TO GET ALL THE ALL THE RECORDS, ALL THE REPORTS, ALL THE INFORMATION. BUT GETTING INFORMATION FROM BALDWIN WAS NOT EASY. ACCORDING TO INVESTIGATORS, IT TOOK MORE THAN THREE WEEKS TO OBTAIN HIS PHONE RECORDS. IS THAT AN UNUSUAL AMOUNT OF TIME? THE FACT THAT IT TOOK SO LONG, I THINK, RAISES A QUESTION IN PEOPLEâS MINDS ABOUT HOW COOPERATIVE WERE YOU AND WHY DID IT TAKE SO LONG? YOU KNOW, IF YOUâRE THE PROSECUTOR, YOU SAY TO A JURY, LOOK, YOU KNOW, IS THIS SOMEONE WHO HAS SOMETHING TO HIDE? IT MAY ALSO HAVE SOMETHING TO DO WITH PROCEDURE. FOR EXAMPLE, THE SHERIFFâS DETECTIVE HAD BEEN PRESSING BALDWIN TO GET A HOLD OF HIS PHONE FOR THEIR INVESTIGATION. IN THE TEXTS TARGET 7 OBTAINED, BALDWIN TELLS THE DETECTIVE, IâM TOLD BY MY LAWYER THAT THE PHONE IS AVAILABLE TO BE SCANNED WHEN YOU STATE IN A WARRANT EXACTLY WHAT YOU WANT. MY PHONE. YOU CAN HAVE EVERY CORRESPOND I HAVE EVER HAD WITH ANYONE RELATED TO THE FILM. THE DETECTIVE RESPONDS TO BALDWIN SAYING, I HAVE NO CORRESPONDENCE FROM YOUR PHONE. ITâS SOMETHING THATâS BEING REQUESTED. IF I NEED TO GO THE WARRANT ROUTE, I WILL. NO PROBLEM. BUT ITâS GOING TO TAKE TIME. DID YOU GET ALL OF THE TEXT MESSAGES FROM ALEC BALDWIN? WE GOT EVERYTHING THAT THE SUFFOLK COUNTY SHERIFFâS OFFICE PULLED FROM HIS PHONE. I DO NOT THINK THAT THAT INCLUDED EVERY TEXT MESSAGE OR PHONE CALL OR PHONE LOG FROM THAT TIME PERIOD. AND WE ARE STILL INVESTIGATING THAT ANGLE. BACK IN NOVEMBER, THE FULL RUSTON VESTA GATION FROM THE SANTA FE COUNTY SHERIFFâS OFFICE WAS RELEASED IN THAT INVESTOR SESSION, IT WAS REVEALED BALDWIN SENT A MESSAGE TO HIS ASSISTANT SAYING, I HAVE TO DELETE MY ARCHIVE. HOW WILL THAT BE USED AGAINST HIM, DO YOU THINK, IN COURT? THATâS A VERY CURIOUS DEVELOPMENT BECAUSE WHAT YOU HAVE IS THAT STATEMENT. AND OF COURSE, HIS TEAM HAS SAID, WELL, HE WAS REFERRING TO HIS TWITTER ARCHIVE. BUT YOUâVE GOT THAT STATEMENT MADE IN CONJUNCTION WITH THE D.A. FROM SANTA FE SAYING WE DONâT THINK WE HAVE ALL OF ALL OF HIS TEXTS. SO THAT RAISES THE QUESTION OF WAS HE REFERRING TO TAMPERING WITH EVIDENCE THAT WERE THERE THINGS HE DIDNâT WANT TO HAVE SEEN BY LAW ENFORCEMENT WERE THE THINGS THAT WERE INCRIMINATED? WERE THERE ANY KEY PIECES OF EVIDENCE THAT LED TO THIS OUTCOME? I WOULDNâT SAY THERE WERE KEY PIECES OF EVIDENCE. IT WAS MORE A TOTALITY OF THE CIRCUMSTANCES, THE LACK OF SAFETY ON SET, THE THE THE NOTIFICATION FROM THE CAMERA CREW THAT THERE WAS A LACK OF SAFETY ON SET. THE MISFIRES THAT HAD HAPPENED EARLIER IN THE WEEKS IN DETERMINING WHAT CHARGES TO FILE, THE D.A. TALKED TO WITNESSES, AN EXPERT ARMORS. THEY ALL SAID THAT DURING THE REHEARSAL IT DID NOT REQUIRE FOR A GUN TO BE FIRED AND THAT A PLASTIC OR REPLICA GUN SHOULD HAVE BEEN USED. WHY WAS HANNAH GUTIERREZ-REED INSTRUCTED THEN TO LOAD A GUN FOR THAT REHEARSAL SCENE? THAT WOULD BE A GREAT QUESTION, ASKED MR. HALLS. WHEN HE HAS TO TESTIFY IN THIS CASE, HOESS ATTORNEY, LISA TERACO, HAS SAID THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR WASNâT THE ONE IN CHARGE OF DECIDING WHAT TO USE AT REHEARSAL. WHAT WAS DAVE HALLâS RESPONSIBLE FOR AND WAS HE RESPONSIBLE FOR SAFETY AT THE SET? IT HAS ALWAYS BEEN OUR POSITION THAT HE IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR SAFETY. HEâS A SAFETY COORDINATOR AND HE HAS THE RESPONSIBILITY OF INFORMING PEOPLE ABOUT SAFETY ISSUES. KORTRIJK DID SHOW THAT BEFORE HUTCHINS WAS SHOT, GUTIERREZ-REED LOADED THE GUN, LOCKED IT INTO A SAFE AND TOOK A LUNCH BREAK WITH THE REST OF THE CREW. WHEN SHE RETURNED AND SHE WAS TOLD TO GIVE IT TO HALLâS AND HE WAS SUPPOSED TO ANNOUNCE THAT THE GUN WAS SAFE. HE DID NOT HAND BALDWIN THE GUN, BUT I DONâT THINK IT MATTERS. YOU KNOW, ITâS BEEN A BIG POINT OF CONTENTION AND ITâS FRUSTRATING BECAUSE I FEEL LIKE WEâRE YELLING AT THE TOP OF OUR LUNGS. HE DIDNâT HAND HIM THE GUN. THE DAâS OFFICE ALSO DETERMINED THAT BALDWIN HAD LIMITED TRAINING TO DO THIS CROSS DRAWER MANEUVER. HE WAS REHEARSING. COURT DOCUMENTS SAY HE WAS SUPPOSED TO GET ONE HOUR OF TRAINING AND GUTIERREZ-REED TOLD INVESTIGATORS THEY DID 30 MINUTES OF TRAINING BECAUSE HE WAS DISTRAUGHT AT IT ON HIS CELL PHONE, TALKING TO HIS FAMILY. ACCORDING TO TEXT MESSAGES AND EMAILS OBTAINED BY TARGET 7. GUTIERREZ, REID HAD VOICED CONCERNS TO HER SUPERIORS FOR TAKING TIME AWAY FROM HER TO WATCH THE GUNS. THEY HAD TOLD HER, YOU KNOW, YOUâRE FOCUSING TOO MUCH ON YOUR ARMOR DUTIES, SHE SAID IN AN EMAIL. ONE WEEK BEFORE THE TRAGEDY. I WANT TO DO A GOOD JOB AND MAKE A GOOD IMPRESSION. BUT ULTIMATELY THERE ARE WORKING GUNS ON SET EVERY DAY AND THOSE ARE ULTIMATELY GOING TO BE PRIORITY BECAUSE WHEN THEY ARE NOT, THATâS WHEN DANGEROUS MISTAKES CAN HAPPEN. DID ALEC BALDWIN HAVE A DUTY TO CHECK THE PROP GUN THAT DAY? I BELIEVE THAT HE DID. IF YOU ARE GOING TO HOLD A GUN POINTED AT SOMEONE AND PULL THE TRIGGER, YOU NEED TO KNOW WHAT IS IN THAT GUN. AND AN ACTOR SHOULDNâT BE TREATED DIFFERENTLY FROM A NON-ACTOR JUST BECAUSE THEYâRE AN ACTOR. THATâS THE WHOLE POINT OF OUR CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM IS THAT EVERYONE IS EQUAL UNDER THE LAW. THE INVESTIGATION INTO THE RUSSIAN SHOOTING ALSO FOUND THAT BALDWIN FAILED TO DUE TO SAFETY CHECKS THAT DAY. GOODYEAR WAS READ, SHOULD HAVE BEEN PRESENT DURING THE REHEARSAL CALL AND SHE WASNâT. AND OTHER THAN BEING THE DAUGHTER OF WELL KNOWN ARMOR FELLOW REID, SHE WAS NOT QUALIFIED AND DID NOT HAVE PROPER CERTIFICATIONS. WHAT I CARE ABOUT IS THAT HALYNA HUTCHINS GOT KILLED BY SOMEONE HAND BECAUSE BECAUSE THEY WERE BEING UNSAFE WITH A GUN. THATâS WHAT I CARE ABOUT. AND THATâS WHY IâM PROSECUTING THIS CASE. HOW MARY CARMACK ALWAYS IS PROSECUTING THE CASE HAS BEEN UNDER FIRE SINCE SHE FILED CHARGES. THE D.A. HIRED SPECIAL PROSECUTOR OR ANDREA REEB, WHO WAS ELECTED TO THE STATE LEGISLATURE JUST MONTHS BEFORE CHARGES WERE FILED. WHY WAS SHE APPOINTED? I ONLY HAVE EIGHT ATTORNEYS THAT HAVE THE EXPERIENCE AND THE SKILL LEVEL TO TAKE HOMICIDES. SO I ELECTED TO BRING SOMEONE ELSE IN THAT HAD 25 YEARS OF PROSECUTORIAL EXPERIENCE TO WORK WITH ME. ALL THREE DEFENSE ATTORNEYS HAVE SAID ITâS IMPROPER FOR REEB TO BE A SPECIAL PROSECUTOR AND LEGISLATOR. ITâS CLEARLY A VIOLATION OF THE SEPARATION OF POWERS CLAUSE IN THE NEW MEXICO CONSTITUTION AND THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION, POSES ATTORNEY LISA TERACO HAD DONATED MONEY TO REEVES CAMPAIGN JUST WEEKS AFTER SHE WAS NAMED SPECIAL PROSECUTOR. REMEMBER HALLâS PLED TO A PETTY MISDEMEANOR WHILE BALDWIN AND GUTIERREZ-REED WERE CHARGED WITH FELONIES. DAVID HALLS WAS GIVEN A ESSENTIALLY A SLAP ON THE HAND. LEGAL EXPERTS THINK I GOT THE SCREAM AND DEAL OF THE CENTURY. I DONâT THINK HE SHOULD HAVE BEEN CHARGED. WHY DID YOU DONATE TO ANDRE REPâS CAMPAIGN? I FULLY EXPECTED THAT SHE WAS GOING TO RESIGN AS SPECIAL PROSECUTOR COME NOVEMBER WHEN SHE WON THE ELECTION. NO MATTER WHO IS FOUND TO BE RESPONSIBLE, THE RUSH SHOOTING WILL FOREVER CHANGE THE LANDSCAPE OF FILM IN NEW MEXICO, IF NOT THE ENTIRE WORLD. QUESTIONS HAVE BEEN RAISED ABOUT WHETHER REAL GUNS SHOULD BE USED ON SET. IF ACTORS NEED MORE TRAINING WITH GUNS AND WHETHER THERE NEEDS TO BE MORE LAWS. ONE THING WE LEARNED IN OUR INVESTIGATION WAS THAT HALYNA HUTCHINS WASNâT GOING TO BE BEHIND THE CAMERA THAT DAY. THINGS CHANGED WHEN CAMERAMEN DIDNâT SHOW UP BECAUSE THEY WERE WORRIED ABOUT SAFETY. IF IT IS A REAL WORKING GUN, YOU ASSUME THAT ITâS LOADED AND YOU TREAT IT LIKE THAT. A WOMAN DIED BECAUSE THISGUN WASNâT TREATED LIKE THE DEADLY WEAPON THAT IT IS FROM THE OUTSIDE. NOT MUCH HAS CHANGED AT BONANZA CREEK RANCH. ON THE INSIDE, IT HAS. THIS USED TO BE A PLACE THAT WELCOMED TOURISTS TO GIVE THEM A GLIMPSE OF LIFE IN THE OLD WEST. ITâS NOW CLOSED TO VISITORS. WE CAN ONLY SEE IT ON FILM THROUGH THE EYES OF CINEMATOGRAPHER FIRMS LIKE HALYNA HUTCHINS, WHO HAVE THE ABILITY TO TAKE US BACK IN TIME TO WORLDS. WE CAN ONLY SEE ON THE BIG SCREEN. FOR THOSE WHO WORK IN NEW MEXICOâS CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM, THEY HOPE THIS TRAGEDY WILL SERVE AS A LESSON TO ALL OF HOLLYWOOD. THE DISTRICT ATTORNEY TELLS US SHE EXPECTS A PRELIMINARY HEARING TO BE HELD BY MAY. THATâS WHEN BALDWIN AND GUTIERREZ-REED WILL RETURN TO NEW MEXICO TO FACE A JUDGE WHO WILL DETERMINE IF THERE IS ENOUGH EVIDENCE TO GO TO TRIAL. HALYNA HUTCHINS VAN EMILY REACHED AN OUT OF COURT SETTLEMENT WITH BALDWIN. PART OF THAT SETTLEMENT IS THAT THE CONTINUED FILMING OF RUST WOULD CONCLUDE OUTSIDE OF THE STATE. FROM ALL OF US HERE AT KOAT. GO
Alec Baldwin pleads not guilty to involuntary manslaughter charge in fatal film-set shooting
Updated: 6:42 PM CST Jan 31, 2024
Actor Alec Baldwin has pleaded not guilty to an involuntary manslaughter charge in the fatal shooting of a cinematographer during a rehearsal on a movie set in New Mexico.Court documents filed Wednesday show Baldwin entered the plea in state district court in Santa Fe, waiving an arraignment Thursday that was scheduled to take place remotely by video conference.Video above: "Rusted": Sister station KOAT' investigation into the 'Rust' movie shootingBaldwin, the lead actor and a co-producer on the Western movie "Rust," was pointing a gun at cinematographer Halyna Hutchins during a rehearsal outside Santa Fe in October 2021 when the gun went off, killing her and wounding director Joel Souza.A grand jury in Santa Fe indicted Baldwin in January after prosecutors received a new analysis of that gun, renewing a charge that prosecutors originally filed and then dismissed in April 2023. Baldwin faces up to 18 months in prison if convicted.Baldwin remains free pending trial under conditions that include not possessing firearms, consuming alcohol or leaving the country. Baldwin can have limited contact with witnesses when it comes to promoting âRust,â which has not been released for public viewing. Baldwin is prohibited from asking members of the âRustâ cast or crew to participate in a related documentary film.Baldwin has said he pulled back the hammer â but not the trigger â and the gun fired.âHalyna and I had something profound in common, and that is that we both assumed the gun was empty ... other than those dummy rounds,â Baldwin told George Stephanopoulos in an interview broadcast in December 2021 on ABC News.The grand jury indictment provides special prosecutors Kari Morrissey and Jason Lewis with two alternative standards for pursuing the felony charge against Baldwin.One would be based on the negligent use of a firearm. A second alternative for prosecutors is to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Baldwin caused the death of Hutchins without due caution or âcircumspection,â also defined as âan act committed with total disregard or indifference for the safety of others.âAn analysis of the gun conducted by Lucien and Michael Haag of Forensic Science Services in Arizona concluded that âthe trigger had to be pulled or depressed sufficiently to release the fully cocked or retracted hammer of the evidence revolver.âAn earlier FBI report on the agencyâs analysis of the revolver found that, as is common with firearms of that design, it could go off without pulling the trigger if force was applied to an uncocked hammer, such as by dropping the weapon. The gun eventually broke during testing.Morrissey and Lewis dismissed the earlier charge after they were informed the gun might have been modified before the shooting and malfunctioned.The grand jury heard from a âRustâ crew member who was a few feet from the fatal shooting and another who walked off the set before the shooting in protest of working conditions. Weapons forensics expert Michael Haag, a Mississippi-based movie armorer and a detective with the Santa Fe County Sheriffâs Office also testified.âRustâ weapons supervisor Hannah Gutierrez-Reed also has been charged with involuntary manslaughter, with a jury trial scheduled to start Feb. 22. She has pleaded not guilty to that charge and a second charge of tampering with evidence in Hutchinsâ death.Gutierrez-Reed also was charged with carrying a gun into a downtown Santa Fe bar days before she was hired to work as the armorer on âRust.â She has pleaded not guilty to that charge, too.The fatal shooting of Hutchins resulted in a series of civil lawsuits, including wrongful death claims filed by members of Hutchinsâ family, centered on accusations that Baldwin and producers of âRustâ were lax with safety standards. Baldwin and other defendants have disputed those allegations.âRustâ assistant director and safety coordinator David Halls pleaded no contest to unsafe handling of a firearm last March and received a suspended sentence of six months of probation. He agreed to cooperate in the investigation of the fatal shooting.
Actor Alec Baldwin has pleaded not guilty to an involuntary manslaughter charge in the fatal shooting of a cinematographer during a .
Court documents filed Wednesday show Baldwin entered the plea in state district court in Santa Fe, waiving an arraignment Thursday that was scheduled to take place remotely by video conference.
Video above:
Baldwin, the lead actor and a co-producer on the Western movie "Rust," was pointing a gun at cinematographer Halyna Hutchins during a rehearsal outside Santa Fe in October 2021 when the gun went off, killing her and wounding director Joel Souza.
A grand jury in Santa Fe indicted Baldwin in January after prosecutors received a new analysis of that gun, renewing a charge that prosecutors originally filed and then dismissed in April 2023. Baldwin faces up to 18 months in prison if convicted.
Baldwin remains free pending trial under conditions that include not possessing firearms, consuming alcohol or leaving the country. Baldwin can have limited contact with witnesses when it comes to promoting âRust,â which has not been released for public viewing. Baldwin is prohibited from asking members of the âRustâ cast or crew to participate in a related documentary film.
Baldwin has said he pulled back the hammer â but not the trigger â and the gun fired.
âHalyna and I had something profound in common, and that is that we both assumed the gun was empty ... other than those dummy rounds,â Baldwin told George Stephanopoulos in an interview broadcast in December 2021 on ABC News.
The grand jury indictment provides special prosecutors Kari Morrissey and Jason Lewis with two alternative standards for pursuing the felony charge against Baldwin.
One would be based on the negligent use of a firearm. A second alternative for prosecutors is to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Baldwin caused the death of Hutchins without due caution or âcircumspection,â also defined as âan act committed with total disregard or indifference for the safety of others.â
An analysis of the gun conducted by Lucien and Michael Haag of Forensic Science Services in Arizona concluded that âthe trigger had to be pulled or depressed sufficiently to release the fully cocked or retracted hammer of the evidence revolver.â
An earlier FBI report on the agencyâs analysis of the revolver found that, as is common with firearms of that design, it could go off without pulling the trigger if force was applied to an uncocked hammer, such as by dropping the weapon. The gun eventually broke during testing.
Morrissey and Lewis dismissed the earlier charge after they were informed the gun might have been modified before the shooting and malfunctioned.
The grand jury heard from a âRustâ crew member who was a few feet from the fatal shooting and another who walked off the set before the shooting in protest of working conditions. Weapons forensics expert Michael Haag, a Mississippi-based movie armorer and a detective with the Santa Fe County Sheriffâs Office also testified.
âRustâ weapons supervisor Hannah Gutierrez-Reed also has been charged with involuntary manslaughter, with a jury trial scheduled to start Feb. 22. She has pleaded not guilty to that charge and a second charge of tampering with evidence in Hutchinsâ death.
Gutierrez-Reed also was charged with carrying a gun into a downtown Santa Fe bar days before she was hired to work as the armorer on âRust.â She has pleaded not guilty to that charge, too.
The fatal shooting of Hutchins resulted in a series of civil lawsuits, including wrongful death claims filed by members of Hutchinsâ family, centered on accusations that Baldwin and producers of âRustâ were lax with safety standards. Baldwin and other defendants have disputed those allegations.
âRustâ assistant director and safety coordinator David Halls pleaded no contest to unsafe handling of a firearm last March and received a suspended sentence of six months of probation. He agreed to cooperate in the investigation of the fatal shooting.